Wednesday, September 21, 2016

Answering Sotnak's Argument on Moral Outrages Objectivity


Photobucket






, "Ethical Subjectivism and the Argument from Outrage." The Secular Outpost
http://www.patheos.com/blogs/secularoutpost/2016/09/18/ethical-subjectivism-and-the-argument-from-outrage/



 Makes an interesting point about the methods of argumet used to justify "objective ethics." [1] He deals with augments that have the following structure:



In arguing for the superiority of theistic ethics over secular ethics, apologists sometimes present some version of an argument like this:1. If theism is not true, then ethics is subjective.2. Ethics is not subjective.3. Therefore, theism is true.
This is the form o argument Craig often uses, Sotnak's argument is that it is emotion that moves the argument it doesn't establish a basis for moral good. The issue is usually that God gives us moral objectivity and yet this is being sold by the use of subjective emotive means rather than logic,




Note the examples that are given: Hitler’s genocidal policies, or torturing children for pleasure. In choosing these examples, the apologist is counting on the audience to feel powerful negative emotions in response to the examples. The suggestion that, say, stomping on kittens isn’t objectively wrong is just outrageous!
The irony, though, is that according to subjectivism, moral judgments are motivated not by reason, but by feeling. And the irony is that the apologetical strategy here only seems to be effective when the chosen examples can be expected to provoke strong negative feelings. Contrast the following two example arguments:
A1. If subjectivism is true, then stomping on kittens is not objectively wrong.
A2. But stomping on kittens is objectively wrong.
A3. Therefore, subjectivism is not true.
And
B1. If subjectivism is true, then gathering sticks on Sunday is not objectively wrong.
B2. But gathering sticks on Sunday is objectively wrong.
B3. Therefore, subjectivism is not true.



The point is interesting but the problem is the oral outrages used for emotional leverage by apologists and I think you are right that is not the ace card thy need to play. But they are not in themselves the grounding of ethical axioms. They merely point to a reality beyond them selves. The reason they outrages us is because they so antithetical to the nature of the good, which grounded in God's love, At some intuitive level we sense that the connivance and hater kin these examples is a violation of the ultimate nature of the good,
We need the regulatory concept because we cant use the intuitive as grounding it can only point to the grounding.
I you will recall the basis of my ethical view point is not objectivity. Even though I believe God is objective hes the only one who is. We can't be objective so must shoot for less subjective. So we need a regularity concept beyond ourselves.


.

He uses a certain concept about slavery as a further example.



Or how about:C1. If subjectivism is true, then buying slaves from foreigners is not objectively wrong.C2. But buying slaves from foreigners is objectively wrong.C3. Therefore, subjectivism is not true.These days, it is hard to find theists (even among Biblical literalists) who will disagree with C2, even though a straightforward reading of the Bible suggests that they should (Leviticus 25:44-46). Why? Isn’t it because they are motivated more strongly by their negative feelings about slavery than they are by speculation about some theistic basis for opposing slavery? Doesn’t subjectivism provide a better explanation for why opposition to slavery is much more common among contemporary theists than it was in America in the mid-1800’s?uf
The problem is he's not proving that theistic ethics is really based upon subjective premises but only that people don't worked up about abstractions, These issues like slavery are used because the users feel that the opponent will be less likely to disagree with the immorality of outrages. Like saying :if you mess around with objective moral values you will wind up justifying things you don't like. That may backfire because it has the effect of seeming to ground axioms kin the subjective. But if we understand that the emotive aspects are only pointers that bid us look at higher reasons the nvit;s not grounded imn those emotive matters.

We have to know what the secularist would turn to as grounding. I think the signpost nature of moral outrage indicates we need the regulatory concept and i doubt the secularist can find one as compelling as God.


From the commemnt section: these comments are telling in that they point up the cultural divide between theists and atheists.

One, we have no basis for saying these things are objectively wrong other than depending on the subjective declarations of God. To say a God's declarations are objective is to misunderstand what objective means. Objective can not depend on any thought or be dependent on anyone's decisions, even a Gods.

Meta: The problem here is you are treating God like he's just another guy, you can't put God in the category of other minds, that's like counting the speedometer a another entry in the race. Saying the referee won the boxing match. God is the basis of reality not just another thing reality. Moreover, God is universal mind, He knows things from each and every perspective, He doesn't just have one more perspective he has the the one true objective understanding, God knows what it is like to be us better than we do ourselves.

Furthermore, if it is based on what we feel is wrong we have no way of knowing if those feelings reflect a divinely inserted feeling of some natural feeling.

Meta:
Yes we do. We have the Bible and that gives us a record of the man God became,me imn history, and we have scientific means of studying religious experience, See The Trace of God Rational Warrant for Belief by Joseph Hinman,m on amazon

I would say we would be less able to actually make beneficial and progressive moral decisions basing them on what we think we feel due to a God's ins crutable actions than with careful thought and reflection on the kinds of things that seem to augment the well-being of people and reduce unnecessary suffering.

Meta:
Empirically disproved both in Bible and in the body of scientific work discussed in my book,.(Jesus died for sins of the world that set's up a pretty good example for moral behavior. So there are standards we can appeal to,




johzek Joe Hinman • 8 hours ago
If it were only a matter of God's understanding then we probably could accurately characterize this understanding as being objective if we felt the need to, after all he knows all the facts and the relationships between them. However, the relevant issue here pertaining to objectivism and ethics is not God's understanding or omniscience but his omnipotence. This being not only created the facts as they are but can change any of these facts at any time at his discretion or whim. This exposes the subjective nature of theism at its core.


Meta:
No that's wrong, right and wrong is based upon arbitrary whim. God is not about might makes right. He has character and right is that which is in harmony with God's character ( love), it;s to stay thiat way, Having the power to change it does not mean he will because God is not shallow
btw omnipotance does not mean the ability to do all things it means all authority. Pantocrator, the Pan prefix means all or everything or everywhere. He has charge in all places,.

It seems to me that a better word to use in this context, that is, in the context of creating and controlling, would be the word "absolute". An absolute moral fact is a moral fact as long as God deems it to be a fact.
Meta:
that's a good point


If as you say "God is a universal mind" and "God is the basis of reality" then a universal mind is the basis of reality. Everything that exists apart from this universal mind and all the facts relating to those things which can be changed at will owe their existence to this mind. This is SUBJECTIVISM.
• Reply•Share ›
No it's the only true objectivity, Universal mind is not localized, God knows your point of view better than you do, he can see it all you see and feel it, He can weight all views equally.
btw I am not worried about being objective,my argument is not that ethics must be objective but that it must be grounded in the absolute, as you say, in unchaining truth always applicable in all cases.God's perfect love ios the only thing that does that.










[1] , "Ethical Subjectivism and the Argument from Outrage." The Secular Outpost
http://www.patheos.com/blogs/secularoutpost/2016/09/18/ethical-subjectivism-and-the-argument-from-outrage/

Sunday, September 18, 2016

The Question of Being, Brute Fact or Deep Structures?

Photobucket


This came up for me on CARM once,when someone made an argument trying to show God is would have to create brute facts. Ohter atheists chimed in saying God w would be a brute fact.


The meaning of the controversy is the difference between Paul Tillich's view of God as being itself, and the atheist understanding that "the universe just is." Tillich said that if we know that being has depth that it's not just "surface only" then we can't be atheists (Shaking of the Foundations, chapter seven). The atheist understanding has long been their answer to arguments like the cosmological argument. When theists divide up mobes of being into necessary and contingent,the atheist merely says "well what if being just is, it has no meaning or reason for being its' just there?" Of course that's a possibility but it doesn't answer the question, and saying it doesn't make the depth we can see in being go away. What is meant by "depth" of being is that there more to being than just the surface fact of things existing. That's what the concept of "the universe just is" tries to convey, the idea of no reason, not no scientific cause necessarily although they do sometimes try to say that too. These are two totally diametrically opposed understandings. The atheist view says being just is, no reason, nothing to consider or worry about, it's just there for no reason, absurdity. The theists seems more to the nature of being than meets the eye from the surface level. There has to be more to it than just the fact of things existing.

The cosmological argument, for example has different versions, but in generally all CA's assert that there must be final cause to account for the existence of the whole of reality. The atheist's often counter this final cause with an infinite series of contingent causes such as the oscillating universe of big bangs and big crunches. This is called an ICR (infinite causal regression). The atheist asserts that the universe just happens to be for no reason and it's made up of a series of little universes that come in and go out of existence. The whole chain, contingent though it may be (some deny validity of the category "contingent") passes on existence to the next version in the form of a big crunch that then expands again in another big bang. Some argue that the crunch (contraction of gravitational forces) becomes a blck hole and "punches out" the other side as a new big bang. This is not the only mechanism for ICR. They also posit the notion of quantum tunneling and string membranes. The oscillating universe, however, is the most popular form of ICR becuase it's the only one with proven potential, even though the evidence disproves it (scroll down to (2) Cyclical Universe). As ICR for origin of the universe quantum tunneling invovles self causation where the singularity, or some original element or fragment of reality keeps tunneling back to cause itself at another point in time. This would involve being just having no logical origin but causing itself over and over eternally. String membrane in the sense of ICR is more or less the idea of a floating dimension just drifting along, bashing into another floating dimension and causing a third dimension. Since it posits the idea of a dimension just floating for no reason (2 actually) why bother with the mess? Why not say the universe needs no origin?

There's no absolute proof in any of this. If we want to get technical there's no actual proof that we are even living in a state of "reality." We assume the reality of the world, and thus our ability to study it and formulate hypothesis that "explain it" but if we want to start special pleading about explainations we don't like and just asserting the unproved nature of origins to hedge bets on those we do then we cant' be too picky when the other guy calls our bluff and says "now it's the skeptic's burden of proof." Why? Because presumption is on the side of explainations. Science assumes we need them. No one ever hears a scientist say "we don't need to explain that, let's forget it." The problem is atheists fool themselves. They demand science so much when they need to reach back to philosophy (Kant--the question about brute facts begins with Kant) it's reaching beyond science to philosohpy, which most atheists condemn anyway. There's a loss of credibility there. More importantly, they have already promised explainations then special plead and say "we don't need them in this area." Hey, for religious experiences we need them and they must be naturalistic!

The idea of "the universe just is," in philosophical terms is called a "brute fact." It means there is no reason it' just there. The problem with brute facts is that philosophers usually avoid them excusable they are meaningless, they are provoking and they beg the question. They are not satisfying. As stated, the explainable has been established as the proper procedure for dealing with unknowns, yet in this one reach of the metaphysical nature of being they are willing to just let it go. It's a true case of special pleading. The unsatisfying nature of the brute fact is set off against the basic intuitive sense of being meaning one finds in the question of existence. Meaning is part of the depth of being and we sense the depth of being in even asking the question "where did it all come from?" The issue seems like an arbitrary stand off, either there is a reason or not. Either there is meaning or not. We can't really tell why think there is when the only thing that we can be sure of is the blind random existence of what is? The scietnific evidence does suggest bind random accident and evolution.

The problem is the brute fact in terms of ICR or universal origin is just made up of contingent things. The states of bang and crunch that make up the oscillating universe, for example, consist of constituat parts such as space-time, gravitational field, and naturalistic things. Naturalistic things are contingent. To posit the whole totality of all universal meaning, eternal truth, the nature of all that is upon a meaningless happenstance that just happens to be, while everything else about existence requires explaining and implies something greater than itself (such as truth) creates a state of dissatisfaction. If we are disatisfied metpahyically we have the right to question that state. ICR and brute facts don't answer the questions we ask. The atheist is content to lose the phenomena and pretend there is no meaning and no answers but in so doing is no better off or no more intellectually justified than the faithful making excuses about "no one knows the mind of God." There is a deciding factor or two and they are a prori part of the basic fabric of the question. There's an aspect to the nature of the contingent happenstance that makes up the brute fact of existence that suggests depth of being in a greater sense.

The eternal and necessary nature being suggests the distinction between being as a brute fact and being as depth. The very mechanism the atheist seeks to ply aging final cause is the disproof of the brutish nature of fact. To explain this I must explain the difference in my CA and that of others. For example the Kalam argument is a version of the CA. This says anything that beings to exist needs a cause. That argument, therefore, turns upon the nature cause. Thus arguments about Kalam revolve around efficient cause in nature, and thus ICR (if allowed to stand) is a valid answer. ICR contains cause even though it means an endless series of meaningless cause the whole of which cannot be explained, our own particular universe has its cause then in the previous big crutch and it's blowing back out as a big bang. My version of the CA, however, the Argument from Cosmological Necessity doesn't turn upon causes but upon attributes of God. The argument turns upon demonstrating that the attributes that make up the God concept already exist and are known to us as aspects of reality, thus it's just a matter of understanding their relation to being we can see that they spell out something deep inherent meaning in being that disproves brute fact. After all if being has a deep inherent meaning it can't be a brute fact, that is a prori truth. The deciding factor is the eternal nature of being. There is another version of the argument that turns upon theeternal nature of being.

The reason it's not a moot stand off between the two concepts is because the ICR itself has to be eternal. the individual aspects of the regression that move from one universe to another are contingent and temporal, but the whole string in so far as it must stretch back eternally is both eternal and infinite. Both states evoke the sense of the numinous. That means it's a fit object of worship because anything that evokes the sense of the numinous is a fit object of worship since that state is the very reason religion exists in the firs place. That's what worship is, its the nature being moved by the sense that there is something profound and special in being. The atheist protest that "the universe just happens to be" is self negating becuase it's eternal and infinite nature suggest the quality of the numinous and are thus more in and of themselves than they perpetual to be. That in itself is depth of being. In seeking to posit the whole they actually must suggest something that triggers religious devotion and thus prove the depth nature of being.

Atheists logically should have to support the concept the universe moving from a state of absolute nothing. This is because the ICR just moves the problem back eternally but never really confronts the issue of origins anyway. Since the atheists affirm the idea of brute fact, meaningless accident, irrational existence, and so on they should actually just take their lumps in abandoning ratinoal explanations. This is not all there, however, the issue is not a done deal. We can't just leap from eternal being triggers the sense of the numinous to "therefore God is real." We have to deal with the other attitudes. Even though they all actually flow out of the eternal nature of being, necessity is the more independent one of the lot. The attrubites I emphasis are:

Eternal
necessary
ground of being
first cause

I am also challenged by atheists constantly to include "consciousness" or "personal being." There is no necessity in theology to assume God is personal. Even though I do assume so that is not a priamry quality because other things are personal as well. I'm concerned with the qualitaties that make God God and that God can't share with anything else. Whatever is eternal is by definition necessary (at least ontologically so) because it's not dependent and can't cease to exist. Nothing else really is necessary in the sense that God is (totally, no nature as the effect of a prior cause), so these are primary qualities. If there is eternal necessary being then by definition it is the ground of being. That would only be logical to assume that it is the first cause since nothing else is on a par with it ti would be the best candidate to assume that all else has it's origin in that which is eternal and necessary.

That brings us to the issue of necessity. This is a very important issue because the whole about ICR includes a large part about necessity vs. contingency. That will be discussed on Monday.

Saturday, September 17, 2016

Obama's Econmy: Helll in a Hand Basket? with 5.1% Unemployment?

Trump still trying to play champion of the common man wshinimng about how we are going to hel in a hand basket, it's a lie.here are the latest figure bureau of labor stats

LATEST RELEASES

MAJOR ECONOMIC INDICATORS

Consumer Price Index

September 16, 2016
On a seasonally adjusted basis, the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers increased 0.2 percent in August after being unchanged in July. The index for all items less food and energy rose 0.3 percent in August after increasing 0.1 percent in July. Full text: (HTML) (PDF)

Employment Cost Index

August 04, 2016
Compensation costs increased 0.6 percent for civilian workers, seasonally adjusted, from March 2016 to June 2016. Over the year, compensation rose 2.3 percent, wages and salaries are up 2.5 percent, and benefits rose 2.0 percent. Full text: (HTML) (PDF)

Employment Situation

September 02, 2016
Total nonfarm payroll employment increased by 151,000 in August, and the unemployment rate remained at 4.9 percent. Employment continued to trend up in several service-providing industries. Full text: (HTML) (PDF)

Producer Price Index

September 15, 2016
The Producer Price Index for final demand was unchanged in August. Final demand prices declined 0.4 percent in July and rose 0.5 percent in June. In August, a 0.1-percent advance in the index for final demand services offset a 0.4-percent decrease in prices for final demand goods. Full text: (HTML) (PDF)

Productivity and Costs

September 01, 2016
Productivity decreased 0.6 percent in the nonfarm business sector in the second quarter of 2016; unit labor costs increased 4.3 percent (seasonally adjusted annual rates). In manufacturing, productivity decreased 0.4 percent and unit labor costs increased 6.7 percent. Full text: (HTML) (PDF)

Real Earnings

September 16, 2016
Real average hourly earnings decreased 0.1 percent in August, seasonally adjusted. Average hourly earnings increased 0.1 percent and the CPI-U increased 0.2 percent. Real average weekly earnings decreased 0.4 percent over the month. Full text: (HTML) (PDF)

U.S. Import and Export Price Indexes

September 14, 2016
U.S. import prices declined 0.2 percent in August, after ticking up 0.1 percent in July. The August downturn was driven by lower fuel prices. Prices for U.S. exports decreased 0.8 percent in August following a 0.2-percent increase in July. Full text: (HTML) (PDF)
Subscribe to the BLS News Service to receive the above news releases by e-mail.

SCHEDULES OF NEWS RELEASES

ALL ECONOMIC NEWS RELEASES

ARCHIVES

Caution

Data in archived news releases may have been revised in subsequent releases. The latest data, including any revisions, may be obtained from the databases accessible on the program homepages.

EMPLOYMENT & UNEMPLOYMENT

Monthly

  • Employment Situation (HTML) (PDF)
  • Commissioner's Statement on the Employment Situation (HTML) (PDF)
  • Job Openings and Labor Turnover (HTML) (PDF)
  • Mass Layoffs (HTML) (PDF)
  • Metropolitan Area Employment and Unemployment (HTML) (PDF)
  • Real Earnings (HTML) (PDF)
  • Regional and State Employment and Unemployment (HTML) (PDF)
Below is an old post fro, Feb but it was not bad even then.



 photo prez_jobs_june2015_zps8n6wk4ez.png
from Daily Kos Site [1]


Trump has made the statement "The country is going to hell in a hand basket." Let's look at the figures? See those little red stumps on the upper graph? That's Bush's Job growth. One is negative. Obama's much better. It's not as good as Clinton's or even Reagan's (see the graph, Clinton blue) but Obama had a much worse economic crisis that he inherited.



From Fact Check.org 

Summary

Since President Barack Obama first took office:
  • The economy has added nearly 8.4 million jobs — more than six times the number gained under George W. Bush.
  • The number of job openings doubled, to a record 5.7 million.
  • Nearly 15 million fewer people lack health insurance coverage.
  • Corporate profits are at record levels; stock prices have more than doubled.
  • However, median household income was down 3 percent as of 2014, and the official poverty rate was 1.6 percentage points higher.
  • The rate of home ownership has dropped to the lowest point in nearly half a century.
  • The federal debt owed to the public has more than doubled — up 107 percent.[2]
The site lists unemployment ratevatv5.1%,  Job openings up 180%,  Business start ups +19%, business failimgs downm 27%

Even a conservative publication such as the Economist says that "the president's record is a lot better than the woes of America's economy suggests." The article points out that Obama faced the most grim economic conditions since 1933, After detailing failure in comic growth and housing market for most of Obama's two terms only picking up late in second term the articles finds all economic recoveries are slow. This a far cry from hell in a hand basket. Since the article is not lauding him as stupendous or berating him for causing every sill since the great depression, it's probably a fairly objective appraisal. [3]



Sources

all sources accessed 2/26/16
[1] Jon Perr, "Obama Has Created Six Times As Many Jobs As Bush," Daily Kos Blog, July 6, 2015,
URL: http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/6/7/1391360/-Obama-has-created-six-times-as-many-jobs-as-Bush

[2] , "Obama's Numbers (October, 2015)," Fact check .org, Posted on October 6, 2015 , blog URL http://www.factcheck.org/2015/10/obamas-numbers-october-2015-update/
Trump's statement was that same month.

[3]  Editor, "End of Term Report,"  The Economist, Sep 2012, online URL:
http://www.economist.com/node/21561909

Tuesday, September 13, 2016

: How Scholarly are Evangelical Academics? Part 2 of 2



 photo original-sin3_zpsrcvrckoc.jpg




"The truth is, had some of these expositors been one tenth as broad as St. Paul on the "woman question," and honest besides, we should never have been taught these pitiful, puerile and ego-centric perversions of Paul's meaning." 
--Katherine Bushnell



In Monday's post i talked about Evangelic scholars and I showered there are clearly many good one,s Today I am dealing with issues where evangelical scholarship is lacking. The three issues I will deal with here are inerrancy, pre Mark Passion Narrative, and issues dealing with women. My real focus will be on the latter.

On inerrancy

In models of Biblical Revelation Avery Dulles (now Cardinal) listed several major views on inerrancy.[1] On Doxa and on Religious a priori I published a chart based upon this work:


Dulles Lists Five Versions of Inerrancy. 

*Inerrancy of original autographs and divine protection of manuscripts.
Proponents of this view include Harold Lindsell.

*
Inspiration of autographs with minor mistakes in transmission of an unessential kind.
Carl C.F. Henry.

*Inerrancy of Textual intention without textual specifics.
Clark Pinnock.

*Inerrancy in Soteric (salvation) knowledge but not in historical or scientific matters.
Bernard Ramm

*Inerrant in major theological assertions but not in religion or morality.
Donald Blosche and Paul K. Jewett 
 [2]

On the one hand they are to be lauded for diversity of view points, On the other hand, since inerrancy is their major issue and the engine that moves their movement doesn't it seem they would have it more nailed down? The thing about inerrancy is that by definition it requires a sort of unified notion of adherence to God's intention. They start creating diversity and dividing inerrancy into different kinds to support the mistakes in a word of God that should have no mistakes. Witness the diversity above it's all aimed at allowing for mistakes in areas such as science and history while making doctrine unassailable, That is also a problem since doctrine is as much the result of human interpretation as science and history. I think we would fair better understanding scripture as the human account of divine-human encounter. Not "the word of God" but contains divine communication.

Pre Mark Passion Narrative (PMPN)

The PMPN is a redaction of the Gospel story prior to the writing of the Gospel of Mark, It deals with a longer stretch of story than just the passion. It includes Jesus' teachings as well as the whole arrest and trail and crucifixion and ends with the empty tomb. Because it pre dates Mark it proves that Mark did not create the empty tomb or the Gospel story, We don't have a full text of it but we find aspects of it in many different writings. Through this PMPN we can date the Gospel including empty tomb by at least AD 55 in writing and probably AD 40s or earlier as oral.[3] This is a powerful tool for supporting the historical validity of the Gospels even though it's major proponents don't believe in the resurrection; Koester and Crosson are two of it's major proponents along with about eight of it's major textual scholars Koestler draws upon. The view is consensus in the field. [4] 

I do not see Evangelicals lining up to use this knowledge. They can't if they want to be uncontroversial because it does mean saying that Mark was not the fist Gospel and thus probably means giving up the namesake authorship. But it does not mean giving up eye witness authorship. Ironically the one person who pushes this is also an evangelical. The one evangelical I know of who is willing to give up Johaninine authorship that is Richard Bauckham. He attributes fourth gospel to elder John of whom Papias speaks,and who wrote the epistles of John, He's also an English evangelical so more willing to stretch the envelope.[5] Ray Brown was instrumental in establishing the nature of the PMPN as independent of the canonical gospels.I don't think of Brown as evangelical but he was a believer, perhaps we could say Orthodox Catholic. So ideas are  valuable for the believing scholar but I don't see the evangelicals being willing to shed their ideology and stretch the envelope enough to use them.

3. Women

Evangelical scholars flock to back the conventional silencing of women. The new scheme is to give lip service to equality but combine it with double talking spelling out the same old status quo, silencing women,and call it "complementarianism." Virtually every single passage about women has some trick of language to it upon which the conventional silencing is based. Any such example reveals willful slip shod scholarship used to reinforce the regime against women's equality. I'll single out two major examples: (1) Gen 3:16, (2) 1 Cor 11:1-12. Gen 3:16 is the alleged curse on woman commanding her subjugation to the male: "your desire shall be to your husband he will rule over you." 1 Cor 11: 1-12 seems to say that women should cover their heads in church as sign of their husband's authority over them. Since I don't have time to cover the full issue of equality of sexes please read my exposition on the issue as a whole ("Women and Christianity").[6]

Gen 3:16 supposedly establishes female subjection to the male, the wife to the husband as a curse for Eve's sin. But the exact reasons for the punishment have always shifted arouind, Ancient Rabis and 19th century clergymen took the phrase "your desire shall be to your husband " To mean that the wife's sexual desire would be so powerful that she would allow herself to be controlled.[7] The new position I saw stacking up way back in the 80s. I researched it and saw there was no basis for it, I taught agaisnt it and sure enoigh here it is made into the commentaries with evangelical stuffed shirts pretending like it's really a big thing. The idea is that she hasd a desire to control her husband, but because of that he will rule over her, The problem is they are not just including that in a study note they have actually put in the translation. Susan Kirzo says the change is not warranted

Christianity Today shared an interesting article about changes that were made to the English Standard Version this summer and it playfully mentioned how the ESV is now "literally the unchanging Word of God" (Read more here).Changes to translations are necessary as language changes, and our Bibles are continuously being updated for this very reason. But what may have gone unnoticed by the casual reader is that these changes included Genesis 3:16. 
Your desire shall be contrary to your husband,
but he shall rule over you.”
This change is not warranted by the original text. Instead it follows current theology, and the new interpretation of the text that now says the woman desires to control the man, as described by Raymond C. Ortlund in CBMW's flagship book Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood: A Response to Evangelical Feminism (Wheaton: IL, Crossway, 1994):[8]
If I remember correctly I think the analysis being added to the new translation originated with Bill Gathard back in the 1980s and has nothing to do with the actual language in the passage; Gathard was not a Bible scholar but an extremely far right wing "teacher" who ran self help seminars. We see the Biblical manhood book is from Wheaten college which is to evangelical scholarship as Rome is to Catholic doctrine. This is a pernicious view because it teaches that woman  is to blame for her subjugation as a  result of her lust for power, Thus feminism and egalitarianism and all woman-freeing ideas are automatically suspect and at the root of woman's grasp for power. There is a perfectly valid interpretation that sees the word "desire" as meaning "turning." That is based upon the Hebrew. She is turning from God to her husband for dependence. Please see my essay on the passage.[9]

The passage in 1 Corinthians 11: "8)For man does not originate from woman, but woman from man; (9)for indeed man was not created for the woman's sake, but woman for the man's sake.
(10)Therefore the woman ought to have a symbol of authority on her head, because of the angels." So because man was made first women must be i subjection, not because of the curse? She must cover her head to signify it? In reality the passage says nothing about covering the head. It actually says "she should have power over her own head," In other words let the woman decide. Paul wants them to cover  because uncovered they look like prostitutes, So  they should, but he's leaving it up to them, The word there is exousion meaning one's own authority, that gets translated totally wrongly as "as a sign of authority."

The word exousian (exousian) means "liberty," "privilege," "authority" but of a kind that is one's own. The Centurian told Christ, "I am a man under authority. I say to one 'go' and he goes and 'come' and he comes." He describes himself as one who must be obeyed, but says he is "under authority," why? Because that is the word exousian. the Centurion's authority was delegated by Rome, but it was his own authority to wield as he saw his duty. It was his privilege to command as he saw fit. The word means one's own power, it does not mean "to be under subjection." It is the woman's own power to veil or not, as she sees fit. Ramsay himself proved this in the Cities of St.Paul. On one of his digs he found a statue of a woman, the inscription of what claimed that she had "three powers on her head." This was Ramsey's rendering, and it was the same word. This meant, she was the wife, daughter and mother of kings.Intermediate Liddell and Scott Greek Lexicon (Oxford, 1983) defines the word: I."Power or authority to do a thing. Magestry, the body of magistrates, authorities, powers." II. "Means, resources." It certainly looks to me as though that word is entirely concerned with the ability of the bearer to work by his/her own perogative, and not subjection to the authority of another. The Barclay Newman Greek Dictionary defines it as "liberty, power, authority, to be in subjection or to wear a vile." I showed that to my Greek professor (a Classicist from Yale) who laughed himself silly saying "the Greeks never had a word like that!" This just shows the bias of Christian publications on this topic.

The legendary Sir William Ramsey Translated it as I do and said in speaking of the convention view, that it means to wear a sign of authority, "a preposterous idea which a Greek scholar would laugh at anywhere (except in the New Testament, where they seem to think Greek words can mean anything commentators choose." [10] As my professor actually did laugh.The problem is magnified by every passage dealing with women, The evangelical reference works like Strong's and Vines are virtually worthless when it comes to this topic.In My article on I go into great detail showing how  Grudem's scholarship is biased on this topic and how poorly he deals with the problem of Lexicons.[11] Also see my article on the 1 Corinthians passage, It has been called "eye opening." [12]

http://www.doxa.ws/social/Women/veil-2.html

all online sources accessed 8/14/16

[1] Avery Dulles, S.J., Models of Revelation. Mayknoll New York: Orbis books, Paperback ed. sixth printing, 2001,.19

[2] Joseph Hinman, "The Nature of Biblical Revelation" Religious A Priori on line resource URL
http://religiousapriorijesus-bible.blogspot.com/2010/07/nature-of-biblical-revelation.html

[3] Joseph Hinman, "Gospel Behind The Gospels part 2" The Religious a priori on line resource URL
[4] Helmutt Koester,  Ancient Christian Gospels: Their History and Developmemt. Bloomsbury: T&T Clark; 2nd prt. edition (March 1, 1992) 215-218

[5] Richard Bauckham,  Jesus and The Eye witnesses: The Gospels as Eye Witness Testimony, Grand Rapids MI: Wm.B. Erdman's Publishing Co. 2006, paperback 2008  420-425


[6] Joseph Hinman, "Women and Christianity" section of Doxa: Christian Thought in 21st Centjury, an online resource (website). URL: http://www.doxa.ws/social/Women/women_index.html

[7] Katharine Bushnell,"The Correct Interpretation of Gensis 3:16" God's Word To Women, Published by council on Biblical Equality 2003. availible on Amazon



free copy



This book was originally written a study guide and thesis not numbered by pages, it was mail order, it was written in the 1920 I believe. At that time it was radical it could not be published but the author was a student of Greek and of Hebrew who studied at Northwestern University, when I studied Greek I read her books and checked her work and found no instances where I found any real disagreement, or any of her views that I could not back up with published scholars. She backs up her point about "desire" (Tesheuqa) meaning turning with massive documentation from ancient sources.

[8] Susan Kirzo, "ESV & the Ever-Changing Genesis 3:16," Suzan Kirzo Blog

9/11/2016 URL:


[9]Joseph Hinman, "curse on Eve?" Doxa Women and Christianity


[10] William Ramsay, Cities of ST. Paul. London: holder, 1907, 203

[11] Hinman, "Meaning of Headship part III battle of thei lexicons" Doxa: Women and Christianity

[12] "Power over her own head," Doxa: Women and Christinaity